Why does the UK have such an obsession with buying rather than renting property?

As the saying goes ‘an Englishman’s home is his castle’. And only in the UK with its obsession with owning your home could such a thing be said. On continental Europe and even in America, owning your own home is for the few with the majority choosing to rent.

The rise in home ownership in the UK has risen inexorably since the Second World War with more than 70% of all adults now owning their own home. And this level of home ownership has important implications for society, for the economy, for politics and even for dinner party conversations.

Why is this?

To let signPost war across Europe many countries invested in large stocks of low cost rented housing built in response to the needs of the growing post war population. In the UK this was in the main delivered through the State via local councils with further contributions from a variety of agencies such as churches, charities and the trade unions in addition to local government. Across Europe, state and social housing remains a very large and important alternative to home ownership.

The UK provided incentives through the tax system to encourage home ownership, putting faith in private investment to meet the housing needs of the population. Mortgage interest tax relief was a staple of the tax system until the 1990s when it was eventually abolished but its effect was to undermine the development of the rental sector as an alternative to home ownership.

Since the war, little attempt has been made to encourage a substantive private rental sector as an alternative to rental properties provided by local government. Indeed there has been a deliberate policy to eliminate investment in a low cost rental alternative in contrast with many other countries.

This tendency in encouraging home ownership and failing to support the rental sector was exacerbated in the 1980s with the policy of selling off council homes at very low cost to their tenants, greatly increasing the levels of home ownership in the UK and significantly reducing the volume of property available for rental.

This lack of supply of a low cost alternative to home ownership and the tax benefits arising from investing in property are at the heart of the UK’s obsession with home ownership but it has been supported and strengthened by the widespread availability of cheap mortgages through building societies, institutions traditionally established as mutuals to help people buy their own homes. This has provided the low cost means to assist people into owning their own property.

And once owning a property becomes the societal norm it becomes the aspiration for all. As the first and second generation of home owners pass on their properties to subsequent generations, the means to invest in property becomes greater and the incentive to invest in the rental sector diminishes.

So there you have it: a perfect virtuous, or economically vicious, circle. And the obsession goes on: it seems that for some time yet we will be talking house prices at our dinner parties.

Written by Ruben Martinez

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

3 Responses to “Why does the UK have such an obsession with buying rather than renting property?”

  1. Hi Ruben,

    Interesting article and I have written a similar one recently comparing the UK and US to Europe.

    There are also other factors, most prominently the fact that European rental contracts are considerably weighted to the tenant and not the landlord. Also because rents are quite low it means a lot of tenants would rather rent than buy.

    I also mention my theory that home ownership will drop in the UK in coming years due to the recent economic conditions. I believe we have entered a new housing cycle completely different to the past.


    PS. if you want to read it you can do here http://jamesdearsley.wordpress.com/2009/08/05/the-future-of-the-uk-property-market/

  2. My views are that we will become a nation of renters. Home ownership, unless prices fall, can never be the right of passage for the the under 30s generation. It is in bred that owning a property is wealth by the back door of debt. The past few years has seen property as a cash cow, the BTL market kicked in the teeth of any first time buyer, maybe we have gone back to the Victorian days of the landed gentry, or should i say the landed BTL speculator. The world economy has been but into debt due to the obsession of buying property, maybe all houses should be built of gold becuse that will be the next bubble that will burst. Owning a home in the past was not an investment is was somewhere to live, not an obsession to keep saying I’m so rich and renting is for the surfs.

  3. It does look like more of us will become renters but will we ever stop paying for our property?

Leave a Reply